Froging AI
首頁

MiniMax H3 Max 實測:四支影片、速度與失敗案例

以四支單次生成影片測試變形、直式動作、台詞與紙城市,除了速度,也記錄動作缺漏、車輪細節及音訊驗證限制。

測試方法:四支皆為單次生成

測試及發布日期為 2026 年 9 月 4 日。四組原創文字提示均以 768P、5 秒、balanced prompt expansion 與安全檢查開啟,各生成一次。兩支為 16:9,9:16 與 1:1 各一支,檢查 10%、40%、80% 影格、尺寸、媒體串流及播放器結果。

測試一:機械蜂鳥組裝成功,飛過鏡頭未完成

提示要求黃銅齒輪、藍色琺瑯板及彈簧組成蜂鳥,振翅後飛過鏡頭。零件組裝與材質延續清楚,但影片 80% 時鳥仍停在桌面,最後飛越動作缺漏,不能只因組裝成功就視為全部指令達成。

測試二:雨中單車快遞,車輪細節仍有限

9:16 提示要求穿黃雨衣的快遞員轉彎、騎過積水並離開畫面。人物、服裝、單車、濕路面與行進方向保持一致,也成功離開鏡頭;但高速時車輪細部變得模糊。輸出 768×1344,推論 2.79 秒,實際等待 6.97 秒。

測試三:陶藝師台詞與手部互動

提示要求陶藝師塑碗、抬頭說短句,再回看陶土。抽查影格中臉部、圍裙、碗、工房及手物關係穩定。存在嘴部動作與 AAC 音軌,但未進行逐字轉錄及音素對齊,因此不宣稱台詞完全正確或精準對嘴。輸出 768×438,推論 2.81 秒,等待 6.85 秒。

測試四:紙城市與 NORTH 字樣

1:1 提示要求摺疊地圖依序展開道路、六棟建築及 NORTH 招牌。藍與珊瑚色紙藝風格、逐步變形及最終 NORTH 表現良好;但開場物件更像紙盒而非交通地圖,單字成功也不能證明普遍文字可靠性。輸出 768×768,推論 1.28 秒,等待 7.29 秒。

區分推論、等待與費用

新計時的三支影片,fal 推論為 1.28 至 2.81 秒,送出至可取得結果為 6.85 至 7.29 秒。三支皆為 5.184 秒、24fps、AAC,四支測試均有 AAC 音軌。2026 年 9 月 4 日 768P 標價為優惠每秒 $0.04、常態 $0.08;五秒估計 $0.20,三支 $0.60,但回應未提供實際帳單或免費額度資訊,這不是實際付款證明。

結論與利益關係揭露

H3 Max 是 fal 後訓練的衍生模型,不等同標準 H3 的官方後繼。適合快速試作與 768P 製作,2K 交付可選標準 H3。本次未做控制條件的 H3 對比,也未測圖片轉影片、尾幀或參考輸入。四支不是統計基準,也未重抽挑選最佳結果。Froging 透過 fal 整合並可由點數使用獲利,但 fal 未贊助或核准結論;作品只經網頁壓縮。

作品範例

MiniMax H3 Max

測試一:機械組裝

蜂鳥成功組裝並振翅,但未完成最後飛過鏡頭的指令。

閱讀原始提示詞

One continuous 5-second macro shot in a sunlit watchmaker's workshop. On a dark worn wooden bench, loose brass gears, cobalt-blue enamel plates, tiny screws, and coiled springs rapidly snap together in a clear sequence to form one palm-sized mechanical hummingbird. As the final chest plate clicks into place, its wings begin beating, fine metal dust lifts from the bench, and the bird launches forward before arcing past the camera. Low eye-level macro camera with a subtle push-in during assembly, then a short rack focus that follows the launch. Warm side light, crisp material detail, physically believable parts and motion, no cuts, no slow motion, no hands, no people, no text, no logos. Audio: precise metal clicks during assembly, a rising mechanical wing hum, a soft rush of air, and quiet workshop room tone; no music.

MiniMax H3 Max

測試二:直式高速動作

單車騎士離開畫面,但高速時車輪細節變得模糊。

閱讀原始提示詞

One continuous 5-second vertical documentary shot on a rainy city side street at blue hour. A bicycle messenger in a bright yellow rain shell rides quickly from left to right, leans through one sharp corner, crosses a shallow puddle that throws a clean fan of water from both tires, then straightens and accelerates out of frame. Low camera tracking parallel to the bicycle at wheel height, holding the same rider in profile through the turn. Natural wet asphalt reflections, believable balance and wheel rotation, jacket fabric reacting to speed, no cuts, no slow motion, no collisions, no text, no logos. Audio: tire hiss on wet pavement, one crisp chain shift, water spray, distant traffic and light rain; no music.

MiniMax H3 Max

測試三:台詞與手部互動

臉部及手物關係穩定,也有 AAC 音軌;未驗證逐字台詞或音素層級的同步。

閱讀原始提示詞

One continuous 5-second naturalistic workshop shot. A ceramicist in her thirties sits at a pottery wheel shaping a small wet clay bowl with both hands. She glances up toward the camera and clearly says, ‘Slow hands make a clean curve.’ She gives a small smile, looks back down, and keeps the bowl centered as it spins. Locked medium close-up, 50mm lens, soft north-window daylight, clay texture and wet fingerprints visible, stable face and hands, no cuts, no subtitles, no text, no logos. Audio: her voice close and natural, steady pottery-wheel hum, wet clay rubbing softly, faint room tone; no music.

MiniMax H3 Max

測試四:紙城市與文字

逐步變形及 NORTH 字樣表現良好,但開場物件較像紙盒而非摺疊地圖。

閱讀原始提示詞

One continuous 5-second stop-motion paper-craft shot, square format, viewed directly overhead on a clean white tabletop. A folded cobalt-and-coral transit map opens by itself in three clear accordion steps. Small paper streets rise first, then six miniature buildings unfold upright, and finally one cream station sign pops up in the center with the single word NORTH printed in bold black capital letters. Crisp cut-paper edges, visible fibers, consistent limited palette, stepped handmade motion, stable overhead camera, no hands, no cuts, no other words, no logos. Audio: three paper folds, soft cardboard pops as buildings rise, then one small wooden click when the NORTH sign locks into place; no music.

常見問題

以四支單次生成影片測試變形、直式動作、台詞與紙城市,除了速度,也記錄動作缺漏、車輪細節及音訊驗證限制。

H3 Max 實際有多快?

新測的三組 5 秒、768P 任務,推論 1.28 至 2.81 秒、實際等待 6.85 至 7.29 秒;會受排隊及網路影響,並非保證值。

台詞與嘴型完全一致嗎?

確認到嘴部動作與音軌,但未做逐字轉錄及音素對齊,不能據此宣稱完全一致。

品質一定比標準 H3 好嗎?

未做相同條件的對照。Max 著重速度及 480P、768P,標準 H3 有 2K,因此不能宣稱所有用途都較好。

相關內容